Article Archive
Agent/Company Issues  
What You Need To Know About the Class Action 

  Item I:  A few people have contacted the NAAFA office saying officials from American Family are suggesting the case is over and AmFam has won. The case is not over. The plaintiffs have filed a petition with the U.S. Supreme Court asking for a review. AmFam's response to the petition is due on October 25. The plaintiffs will then have 14 days to file a reply brief. The Supreme Court could make a decision to grant the petition and hear in the case as early as December of this year. The plaintiffs (agents) are excited because the Stanford Law School Supreme Court Litigation Clinic has agreed to represent the agents on the appeal to the Supreme Court.

Remember, although Jammal won in the district court, AmFam won in appellate court on appeal. Because the plaintiffs believe the appellate decision caused a circuit split, Judge Nugent stayed the district court case pending a decision by the Supreme Court. So there is no winner until word comes from the Supreme Court. Of course, NAAFA members have been kept up-to-date on these and other issues through the Directly to Members…Directly from NAAFA column on the member-side of

Read the petition filed by the plaintiffs with the US Supreme Court on August 22nd by clicking on the link in Item II and read American Family's response in by clicking on the link in Item III..  10/28/2019

UPDATE:    NEW —  Item IV

     Item II:   Plaintiffs Petition for a Writ of Certiorari
     Item III:  Respondents (American Family) Brief in Opposition

     Item IV:  Plaintiff's Rebuttal to AmFam's Brief in Opposition -- 11/13/2019
Zurich's New CEA Greco Reorganizes Company, Simplifying Structure!  6/17/16
Executive Suicides Shock Business Community in Switzerland!  6/6/16
Martin Senn, Former Zurich CEO Commits Suicide  6/6/16
Noncompete Agreements a Tricky Target For Obama Administration  5/17/16
Wells Fargo Weighing Sale of Insurance Brokerage Business: Bloomberg:  5/9/17
American Family Reports Strong 2015 Results.  3/3/16
Top 20 Claims Satisfaction Rankings.  3/2/16
MN: Exams of 16 Life Insurers Find $174M in Unpaid Benefits, So Far!  2/16/16
Could Cyber Kill the Insurance Industry?  1/19/16
The Independent Contractor Guide and How to Find Work as an Independent Agent 1/7/16
The 2015 Fall-Winter NAAFA Report  12/29/15
Best, Worst States for Insurance Regulation: 12/8/15
5 Ways Google Insurance will Disrupt the US Auto Insurance Industry  11/23/15
The Case for Independent Agency Optimism 11/5/15
Drug Prices much Higher in US than in Other Countries:  10/13/15
Zurich's Losses Lead to 'Negative' Rating Outlook from A.M. Best  10/5/15
How Independent Agents Can Give Customers What They Expect  9/13/15
How Homeowners Can Protect Property Before the Next Big Earthquake  8/30/15
9 Investigates: Insurance Companies Cutting Corners on Safety.  8/27/15
A Rich Financial Realm Run Almost Without Oversight  8/25/15
>When Reconstruction Often Costs More Than New Construction:  8/17/15
24 Car Insurance Companies Ranked on Shopping Experience Satisfaction  5/20/15
2014 American Family Corporate Salaries - Top Ten Officers  5/13/15
2014 American Family Corporate Salaries - Complete List!  4/1/15
Top 10 Employment Discrimination Claims  2/9/15
How States Rate on Insurance Regulation, ‘A’ to ‘F’
 Click here to reference the Report Card.
MN Supreme Court Rules Against Ins. Co. in Key Storm Damage Dispute:  12/18/14
American Family Insurance Fosters Start-ups through Venture Capital Arm!  10/10/14
10 Things to Know About Auto Insurance!  9/12/14
If You Have Poor Credit, You May Pay Nearly Double for Home Insurance!  8/8/14
AssureStart in Washington names Zenner Chief Marketing Officer  8/8/14
Reinsurer Wants $100M Back After 'Falsified' Storm Report!  7/10/14
AssureStart Expands Online Small Business Insurance Sales to Three More States!"  6/21/14
TWFG Adds 10 Branch Agencies in Texas!  6/20/14
Agents React to Walmart, Overstock in Ins: "We aren't Dead or Dying, We are Evolving!"  6/13/14
Farmers Withdraws Climate Change Suit against Municipalities!  6/4/14
Has Online Shopping for Auto Ins. Peaked?  5/20/14
10 Best Companies for Homeowners' Claims Experience!!  3/1/14
Insurance Executives Hitting the Jackpot!  2/18/14
Should You Try Pay-As-You-Drive Insurance?  1/24/14
Claggett & Sykes Law Firm Obtain Binding Arbitration Award Against American Family Insurance: 12/9/13
How Allstate Plans to Outflank its Online Rivals! 11/18/13
Homeowners have Stormy Relationship with Adjusters! 10/4/13
Allstate CEO Says Geico Could Struggle with Storefront Strategy! 9/11/13
AmFam Makes Another Direct Move: Buys Homesite for $616 Million! 9/6/13
American Family's 2012 Annual Report! 9/4/13
Five Shameful Ways the US is Leading the World! 8/24/13
The Summer 2013 NAAFA Report! 8/17/13
Allstate Says Book Value to Rise on Cut in Employee's Retirement Benefits! 7/13/13
Car Insurance Satisfaction Slips as Rates Rise! 6/29/13
Three Insurance Companies Placed in Liquidation in Illinois 5/25/13
46 Insurers in Fortune 500 5/11/13
Interest in Personal Gun Liability Ins. Protection Increasing! 4/13/13
Judge Reduces Nationwide Agent's Jury Award! 3/10/13
5 Insurers Make List of Top 50 Companies for Executive Women! 2/8/13
The grass is always greener…or so they say... 2/8/13
AmFam's Purchase of the General - Another Slant 1/25/13
Ohio Jury Smacks Nationwide 11/9/12
Independent Agencies Continue Growing in Number, Revenue! 10/26/12
American Family to buy The General... 9/26/12
The Glass Door 9/15/12
Two American Family Insurance  9/14/12
An Irate Customer Threatens Insurance Agent! 8/11/12
Ellsworth woman sues American Family! 8/31/12
Do Insurance Brokers have to Offer the Cheapest Coverage? 8/25/12
7 Employer Danger Signs: “When to Turn Down a Job Offer” 7/23/12
The Future of Producer Compensation! 7/20/12
Agent's Secretary Gets Slap on Hand! 6/7/12
JD Power Ranks Insurers on Customer Service! 5/6/12
Why Agents & Customers Choose Higher-priced Insurers! 4/12/12
Former Agency Assistant to Spend Time in Jail! 1/9/12
The IRS is offering a break 9/26/11
Allstate Agent Association (NAAPA) Votes Overwhelmingly to Affiliate with OPEIU 8/17/11
The NAAFA Survey Results are Here!  
Rumors Almost Always Have an Element of Truth! Are These Rumors Too Serious To Ignore?  
Begin To Decide Your Future Now!  
Allstate Agents Hope Unionization Sparks Changes at Insurer 7/27/11
JD Power and Associates Reports 7/27/11
Allstate Outlines Its Agent and Direct Distribution Strategies! 5/30/11
American Family Pays Arizona Homeowners $1.2M to Correct Mistake! 5/20/11
THE NEW YEAR—a time for reflection — an Agent’s Perspective!  
The 350 Most Admired Companies!> 3/11/11
JDPower Names Six Insurers Customer Service Champions! 2/26/11
Courts Allowing Private Facebook Posts as Evidence in Lawsuits! 2/24/11
Should More CEO's be Fired? 2/11/11
Judge Awards $11.7M to Agents whose Commissions were Improperly Cut! 1/15/11
Is Your Boss Guilty of Any of the Seven Deadly Sins? 12/11/10
Where is American Family in the JD Powers Survey? 8/7/10
Does American Family’s B- Rating Concern You? 
PRICE IS CRITICAL and this article definitely confirms it! 6/30/09
Personal Beliefs + Corporate Culture Produce Unethical Behavior 10/8/10
Where is American Family in the Market Force Information Survey? 10/2/10
The New Weiss Rating for American Family (B-) 8/21/10
5 Ways to Ensure Mediocrity in your Organization! 6/1/10
Jersey Shore' Scares Off Another Sponsor |! 1/2/10
Protect your Privacy on Facebook and Twitter! 10/3/09
How the Mighty Fall! 9/10/09
Do You Really Want to Join AmFam’s FACEBOOK Page? 7/11/09
Results of NAAFA Survey Regarding Loss of income! 6/15/08
Breaking News Archive  
AmFam to Pay $1.2M to Brain Injury Victim after Denying Claim 10/29/13
AmFam sells Bldg in West Wichita 10/26/13
Ex-Ins Agent Enters Plea in Mail Fraud Case 9/25/13
AmFam Ending Health Ins-hurting our customers, too. 8/28/13
Travelers to Cut Auto Insurance Rates to Battle Competition 7/26/13
Dead Being billed for Life Ins. 6/24/13
Complaint Review: American Family Ins. 5/31/13
Home Ins Claimants Using Agents Happier Than Those Who Don't 4/13/13
AmFam Income up in 2012 3/8/13
NJ Gov Christie Says Fed Flood Ins Program is a Disgrace 2/15/13
Pru close to Buying Hartford Life 9/28/12
InsureZone Acquires MSI Group, Adds Agencies to Direct Program 9/10/12
ASNOA Welcomes New Partners in Missouri, Ill 9/9/12
AmFam Launches Online Home Inventory Service 7/28/12
Ten Best Auto Ins Websites (Where's AmFam?) 6/12/12
What to Expect if Supreme Court Strikes Down Obamacare! 4/27/12
P/C Insurers Face Obstacles on Road to Hard Mkt 3/5/12
Allstate Offers Claim Satisfaction Guarantee! 1/6/12
AmFam 3rd in Claims Satisfaction! 10/28/11
Small Businesses Feel Left Out! 9/28/11
Free Auto Ins: GM & MetLife Team Up! 7/30/11
Allstate Targets Online Ins. Sales! 5/22/11
AmFam's Salzwedel to Become Chairman, CEO! 2/11/11
Whistleblower Lawsuit against Allstate, Others Dismissed! 1/28/11
FEMA Announces Transition Flood Policy! 12/24/10
The Future of Class Actions on Wal-Mart Case Review! 12/11/10
NY Court Rules Against Agent Groups! 11/26/10
After Elections, New Commissioners Could Number 25! 11/6/10
Work of NAIC Will Continue Despite Turnover! 10/22/10
IRS/States Crackdown on Employers' Use of Indep Cont's 2/27/10
Why do your clients want you as their insurance agent! 10/20/10
Zurich Settles Class Action $455M! 10/7/10
Senate Extends Flood Ins for 1 Year! 10/2/10
Poor Service Leads to Fraudulent Ins Claims! 10/2/10
Supreme Court Justices May Weigh Obama Conquest! 4/2/10
Credit Scoring Alternatives examined by Some Insurers! 12/18/09
Car Insurance Rates Dropped in 2009! 12/11/09
California Agents Win Case Against State Farm! 11/13/09
3 States Accuse FedEx of Misclassifying Drivers as Indep. Contractors! 10/31/09
Allstate to agents: Bulk up! 10/10/09
IRS to Audit 6000 Companies to Test for Employment Tax Compliance! 10/3/09
Allstate to Pay $4.5 M to settle EEOC! 9/19/09
Insurance Legislation Surges This Year In Congress, Legislatures! 9/19/09
Can You Sue Your CEO? 8/29/09
Michigan Court Upholds Ban on Credit Scoring in Insurance! 8/1/09
Need for Federal Insurance Czar is Questioned! 7/11/09
Truly Listening to What Agents Have to Say! 6/30/09
Northwestern Mutual sued for $200 million! 6/30/09
Financial Crises is Biggest Risk Facing Insurance Market! 6/24/09
Protect Yourself from Insurance Fraud! 6/9/09
Life At American Family is Not At All Fun Anymore! 6/6/09
Study: Insurers’ Customer Retention Critical in Hard Economic Times! 5/2/09
Troubled Insurance Industry is Making Changes to Confront Critical Issues! 5/2/09
THE INFLUENCE GAME: Insurers eye new regulator! 4/25/09
The End of Private Health Insurance! 4/18/09
Say What You Mean: Character, Integrity, and Independent Agents! 4/11/09
AM Best Revised AmFam to Negative! 3/28/09
In Memory of Wayne Barber! 3/8/09
American Family Mut Ins Co 2008 Profile! 3/7/09
Midwest Storms Batter American Family! 3/6/09
American Family Reports Losses of Nearly $300 Million! 3/3/09
State Farm Sees Record Drop in Net Worth! 2/28/09
Allstate Cuts Dividend in Half, Ending 14 Year Streak! 2/28/09
American Family to Add 46 Jobs in Peoria! 2/28/09
AmFam One of Nine Homeowner Insurers Subpoenaed Over Use of Credit Scores! 1/23/09
Miracles Do Happen! 12/13/08
AIG restricts Exec Compensation, CEO gets a Dollar! 11/29/08
AIG to Terminate Voluntary Deferred Compensation Plans! 11/29/08
Top 5 Reasons Why "The Customer is Always Right" is wrong! 11/22/08
Treasury Dept Worries Insurers on Verge of Collapse! 11/15/08
Insurance Industry Faces a New Political Reality! 11/8/08
Agent Alert! AmFam Director Slams Agents and Plus System! 10/10/08
Social Security Benefits to Go Up by Larger-than-Usual Amount! 10/8/08
Ten Worst Insurance Companies! 9/6/08
Liberty Mutual Buys Safeco! 4/24/08
Federally Regulated Insurance? 4/5/08
Performance Based Exec Pay? 3/23/08
Farmers Ins Coming to Wisconsin 2/9/08
Colorado House Votes Against Credit Score Ban 1/31/08
AF Fires Top Financial Officer 1/26/08
Just A Quick Thought 1/26/08
Credit Scoring Class Action 1/26/08
Recent News Items Archive
TWFG Acquires Ward Business Insurance: 12/13/13
Authorities Search for 2nd Person in Domestic Dispute with Shots Fired 9/25/13
Will 3rd Time be the Charm for National Producer Licensing Bill? 9/24/13
Insurance Costlier for Blue Collar Workers! 7/26/13
Car Insurance: Hidden Discounts Revealed: 7/13/13
Senator Hatch says Ins Firms Can Ease US Pension Crisis! 7/13/13
Mobile Insurance Agent who Accused Farmers of Lying Wins $2.4M Lawsuit! 4/6/13
Agents Hang Onto P/C Market But Lose Ground in Personal Auto! 3/16/13
TWGG's New Appointments bring Branch Mark near 300! 2/23/13
On which holiday is your vehicle most likely to be stolen? 1/11/13
Ohio Sidewalk Driver Does 'Idiot' Sign Time: 11/23/12
Insurance Company Plans Ohio Locations! 6/12/12
Allstate Ad Blitz Follows Sales Hit! 5/5/12
Insurance distributionis changing and agents should be prepared. 1/29/12
Allianz, AmFam & 15 Others Receive Ratings Updates! 12/20/11
Allstate Drops N Carolina HO's Who Insure Autos Elsewhere! 11/28/11
MO Pastor Pleads Guilty in Death of Congregant, a Farmers Ins Agent! 10/26/11
Nationwide to Acquire Harleysville Ins 9/29/11
Allstate Agents Assoc Votes on Guild! 7/22/11
4-Things Agents Should Do To Avoid E&O Claims! 7/1/11
Wells Fargo Settles Sex Discrimination Claims for $32 Million! 6/15/11
Iowa Man Accused of Beating up Boss, An Insurance Agency Owner! 4/29/11
See where AmFam ranks in P & C market share, according to NAIC! 3/4/11
Allstate, State Farm Workers Arrested in Roles in Auto Fraud! 10/15/10
$4M Home Insured by American Family for 8 Days Burns in Des Moines! 8/30/10
Why isn’t American Family on Ward’s List of Top 50 Performing P/C Insurers?! 7/30/10
Obama Signs Bill Extending Flood Program! 7/09/10
Dangerous Dog Owner Must Insure it for $50K! 7/02/10
Allstate Denies Agents' Group Claim it Plans to Cut 3300! 2/06/10
Allstate to Shed Agents! 2/06/10
Review: American Family Insurance! 1/09/10
Michigan Court Upholds Ban on Credit Scoring in Insurance! 9/02/08
Florida Insurance Salesman’s Shoe Found in Stomach of Slain Bear! 8/30/08
American National Hit With $66M Jury Award! 8/16/08
Farmers Adds Pets to Auto Policies! 8/9/08
AmFam Wins 1st Place in Insurance Journal’s 2008 Super Regional P/C Insurers! 7/7/08
Do Gas Prices Drive Auto Insurance Rates Up? 7/7/08
State Regulators Call for More Study of Credit Scoring Use in Insurance! 6/7/08
State Farm Faces Class Action Law Suit! 5/23/08
State Farm Leads in Customer Satisfaction 2/23/08
New Study Shows Investors View Securities Arbitration as Biased and Unfair! 5/5/08